One dog walks at your knee for a whole hour but comes home tense. Another covers a shorter distance, sniffs a great deal, sometimes walks ahead, sometimes turns to look at you, and sleeps peacefully after the walk.
Which one walked “correctly”?
The old pack-leader model would have a very clear answer: the dog must be beside or behind you, because whoever walks in front is in charge. But where on the path a dog walks says nothing about a family’s hierarchy. What matters far more is whether the lead is loose, whether the dog can hear you, whether you are managing safety, and whether the walk satisfies not only the muscles but also the nose.
One walk can contain several modes
There is no need to choose between perfect heelwork and total freedom. Simply separate the tasks clearly.
By a road, on a narrow path, in a crowd or when passing others, you can ask the dog to walk closer. In a safe green space a longer lead allows exploring and sniffing. Sometimes a loose lead is deliberately trained for a few minutes, after which the dog gets a cue meaning “you may explore”.
When a rule depends on a clear cue and the surroundings, it is not contradictory. A dog can learn that “heel” is a specific position, while an everyday walk allows wider movement as long as the lead stays loose.
Why dogs pull
Usually because pulling works. The dog pulled — he reached the tree. Pulled — he got to the other dog. Pulled — he got out of the door faster. Every goal reached reinforced the same way of moving.
It is not necessarily an attempt to take charge. The dog may be excited, afraid of being left behind, wanting more distance from a sound, hurrying towards a smell, or simply not yet understanding lead pressure.
So first choose suitable equipment. A well-fitting harness should not restrict the shoulders or rub the armpits. A simple lead a few metres long offers more options than a very short one that is constantly taut. In an open, safe space you can use a long lead, but it must never be wound around your hands or attached to equipment that presses painfully on the neck.
How to teach a loose lead
Start where the surroundings are less interesting than you are. Mark and reward the moments when the lead is loose, the dog looks round or comes closer of his own accord. Take a few steps, change direction, stop and move again.
When the lead tightens, there is no need to jerk. You can stop, gently change direction or call the dog back. Movement continues when the lead goes slack. That way the journey itself becomes the reward.
It is important not to demand too much too soon. A dog who walks beautifully in the garden cannot yet do it at the school gates. Increase only one difficulty factor at a time: the distance covered, the length of the exercise, or the number and intensity of distractions.
Sniffing is not misbehaviour
A dog’s nose gathers information a person does not even notice. Sniffing can slow the pulse, help him orient himself and provide meaningful mental work. A walk in which the dog only mechanically follows your pace and is never allowed to stop loses a large part of its value.
This does not mean the dog chooses every direction. You decide where it is safe to go and when it is time to move on. But letting the dog choose which verge to sniff for a few minutes is not handing over authority.
Boundaries and choice can exist together.
Doors are a question of safety, not status
Old advice pays a great deal of attention to who goes through the door first. The practical part matters — the dog must not shoot into the street, knock over a child or jump out of the car without permission. But you do not need to step through ceremoniously first every time in order to keep your authority.
Teach it more simply: your hand reaches for the handle, the dog stays in a safe place; the door opens a crack, calmness opens it wider; rushing stops the process. A release cue clearly says when he may move.
If the puppy badly needs to go out, safety matters more than a long display of waiting.
For an Australian Shepherd a walk is also a lesson in movement
Bicycles, runners, children, scooters and cars can trigger an Aussie’s urge to follow or block them. There is no need to wait until the dog starts chasing. Notice the trigger earlier, increase the distance and reward the dog for glancing at it and then focusing on you again.
Chasing a ball every day will not necessarily reduce this need. Sometimes it only trains an even faster reaction to movement. Sniffing, changing direction, watching calmly and being able to walk on build far more transferable skills.
A good walk is not an exam in which a dog spends an hour proving his obedience. It is moving together, where you are responsible for safety and the dog gets to be a dog.
Read next: How to pass another dog calmly